Taste is easy to claim. Harder to demonstrate. Here's what it actually looks like when it's real.

Taste is one of those words that gets used constantly in creative education and defined almost never. Everyone in the design department claims it. Creative directors hire for it. Studios build reputations on it. But ask someone to explain what it actually looks like in practice, in the day to day decisions of a working designer and the answer gets vague quickly. 

So here's a more useful question than whether you have good taste. Here's how to tell.

You know something is wrong before you can explain why

The first and most reliable sign of developing taste is a feeling of dissatisfaction that arrives before the reasoning does. You look at something you've made and something is off, not technically, not structurally. Just wrong in a way you can't immediately articulate. That feeling is taste working. The ability to name what's wrong comes later and with practice. 

The feeling itself is the signal worth paying attention to. Designers who don't have it yet accept the work. Designers who do can't.

You can explain what's wrong with work, not just whether you like it

Preference is not taste. Saying something doesn't feel right is the beginning of a taste observation. Not the conclusion. The designers with developed taste can move from the feeling to the reasoning. They can identify what isn't working, why the decision that produced it was the wrong one and what a better decision would look like. 

That ability is built through looking seriously at a lot of work over a long period and asking the same questions repeatedly until the answers come faster.

Your references are specific and you know why they matter

Vague influences are a taste warning sign. 

A designer with developing taste doesn't just admire work broadly. They can tell you which specific decisions in a specific piece of work are worth studying, why those decisions were harder to make than they look and what they reveal about the thinking of the person who made them. Specificity of reference is one of the clearest external signs of taste because it proves the looking has been active rather than passive.

You're harder on your own work than anyone else in the room

The gap between what you made and what you know it could be is where taste lives. Designers with good taste are almost always their own most demanding critics, not destructively, but with a clear sense of the distance between the current version and the right one. 

That dissatisfaction is productive when it drives revision. It's also a reliable indicator that the standard you're holding the work to is high.

You know the difference between what you like and what is good

Personal preference and considered judgement are not the same thing and developing taste requires being honest about the difference. Something can be outside your aesthetic sensibility and still be excellent. Something can appeal to you immediately and still be weak. The designers who develop real taste over time are the ones who learned to hold both responses at once, to say this isn't for me and this is well done without those two observations cancelling each other out.

Truly good taste shows up in the decisions and the things that get removed. If you're starting to feel it working, that's the sign worth trusting.

Grab yourself a flat white and pull up a seat. The real course is just beginning.

Open All Hours is a digital coffee house for creatives who care about design, brand, and the ideas shaping culture. If you want to join the conversation in the house as it happens come and follow us on Instagram at Open All Hours

The espresso is always on.

Shot of the good stuff.

Taste More Blends

View more